SnitchSeeker.com - View Single Post

Simple Muggle · 12-23-2005, 09:19 AM

I think Mike was the best. He did a very good job!
now, see, GoF is like incompletely complete.
the essence of the book is there.

next is Chris.
He did a good job as well but comparing the books, the SS and CoS book was thin compared to GoF. I mean, he doesnt have a choice but to put everything in the movie though he did cut some things, those things are very tiny infos. so tiny that one wouldnt even notice that it was missing in the film.

Alfonso.
what has he done to PoA..
there's very little in the movie!
though, I must admit, the added R/Hr moments was really brilliant!

I dont hate any of the directors.
in rating, I like Mike the best then Chris then Alfonso.
they're 3 different directors. they have their own directing styles.

12-23-2005, 09:19 AM	#3 (permalink)
Simple Muggle Ron's Krum Envy Niffler Join Date: Apr 2005 Location: Slumberland Posts: 2,913	go sir Mike I think Mike was the best. He did a very good job! now, see, GoF is like incompletely complete. the essence of the book is there. next is Chris. He did a good job as well but comparing the books, the SS and CoS book was thin compared to GoF. I mean, he doesnt have a choice but to put everything in the movie though he did cut some things, those things are very tiny infos. so tiny that one wouldnt even notice that it was missing in the film. Alfonso. what has he done to PoA.. there's very little in the movie! though, I must admit, the added R/Hr moments was really brilliant! I dont hate any of the directors. in rating, I like Mike the best then Chris then Alfonso. they're 3 different directors. they have their own directing styles. __________________ Thanks to the wonderful xiiWishiWasYours