Quote:
ok, i loved GoF, dont get me wrong it was amazing, but i think Dumbledore was not very well portrayed. in my opinion, Dumbledore is supposed to be a man that is almost fatherly towards Harry, always gentle and calm and never angry or violent. (this is how he was in the 1st and 2nd movie) in this movie however...he physically shakes harry and yells at him and is violent! is this really how dumbledore is supposed to act? maybe its just the actor but i was kind of dissapointed. Dumbledore gets all distressed and yells all the time which is not very dumbledorish in my opinion.
this is just how i feel, but does anyone else feel this way?
|
Quote:
i agree.
i prefer Richard Harris's version of Dumbledore, exactly like in the book.
Michael Gambon however doesn't really fit, including that silly little hat he always wearing.
|
I'm with both of you, guys. I'm not alone then.
Quote:
|
but I feel like Gambon's performance in GoF was more humanish... Dumbledore gets upset at Harry because he's afraid that he will get killed and I think that's very true to real life... my parents get angry at me if they're really concerned that I'm going to do something stupid.
|
DD's charcater is not like that. We know DD from the stories. Rowling did his react towards Harry's being a champion is not what Mike had done at the movie. And because Rowling is the one who
invented this character so DD is what Rowling made not what Mike/Kloves or Gambon did.