I'm disappointed that Dobby isn't in the film, I really like him as a character. I am also disappointed that S.P.E.W isn't going to be in it, not even hinted at in one line or anything. Like Ron could mention it or the audience could see Hermione making badges, of course it isn't the main plot but I feel it would do the film version of Hermione to be more like the book version, i.e. more of a bookworm like she was in the first film!

Anyway, I'm pleased with what has been filmed and think that if Neville is the one who gives Harry the gillyweed it'll be fine as Emma said it does fit into his character.